Springfield armory xd compact .40 . smith & wesson , I would like to know my readers’ experiences with these two weapons. how do they stack up against each other, aside from the fact that they are both made of modern. Smith & wesson &p-9 shield – range report – gun, Smith & wesson wisely opted to stick with high-end materials for the shield, with a stainless steel slide and barrel finished in black melonite for maximum corrosion. Glock g17 . smith wesson mp 9mm - handgun forum, Glock doctor tested, mother approved. the g17 is the original that started it all. the first commercially manufactured polymer pistol to take off in the mainstream..